John Mellencamp – “Again Tonight” – (1991)

This could have totally been the b-side for “Hurts So Good.” Sorry, Mr. Mellencamp, but your sound hasn’t evolved all that much in the past 30 years. This was a #1 on the Mainstream Rock chart, but it only hit #36 on the Hot 100. It’s not that rock-y that I feel it would’ve performed better on one chart over the other, but it was 1991, and things were weird.